The Gravedigger of the Academy: Courbet’s Private War and Pavilions
- Art d'Histoire
- Jan 29
- 3 min read
In the history of art, 1855 is usually remembered for the first Universal Exhibition in Paris. But for Gustave Courbet, it was the year he decided to declare war on the French state. While the official jury accepted eleven of his paintings, they rejected his monumental masterpieces, A Burial at Ornans and The Artist's Studio, most likely due to a lack of space.
Courbet’s response was not to sulk, but to secede. He orchestrated a "great burial" of the official art world, transforming himself from a mere painter into an entrepreneur of the avant-garde.
Artillery Batteries and the Role of the Gravedigger
Courbet’s rebellion was premeditated. Long before the jury’s rejection, as early as January 1854, he was already plotting an independent show. Writing to his patron Alfred Bruyas, he used aggressive military terminology to describe his work. He referred to his paintings as "batteries"—cannons designed to bombard the fortress of academic art.
He relished the destructive potential of his plan, writing: "You have to admit that the role of gravedigger is a fine role, and that sweeping the earth clean of all that rubbishy jumble is not without its charms". His goal was to wipe the slate clean of the "old school" and install The Courbet’s Pavilions as the new center of gravity for modern art.
The Temple of the Avenue Montaigne
Courbet literally set up shop right next to his enemies. He rented a site at 7 avenue Montaigne, just a stone's throw from the official Palais des Beaux-Arts. There, he erected a temporary structure that he described as an "enormous tent" with a single column in the middle and walls made of wooden frames.
When the building was completed in June 1855, Courbet triumphantly declared: "The temple is finished". Inside, he displayed forty works, including the rejected masterpieces. Over the door, he placed a sign that would change art history: REALISM. The noble separation of art from mere craft and its trivial merchandising habit was directly challenged.
The "Famous Bazaar" and the Scandal of Money
What shocked the public most was not just the art, but his open business approach, despite there being some illustrious precedents. Courbet charged an entrance fee of one franc. In the 19th century, this was seen as a vulgar commercialization of culture. Critics mocked the pavilion as a "famous bazaar" or a sideshow, comparing it to a "Guignol theatre" (puppet show) set up next to a grand opera house.
Courbet fully embraced this shocking commodification. He consciously chose the term "Exhibition"—an English word that implied charging money at the door—over the traditional French "Exposition." He calculated he would make 40,000 francs, turning his rebellion into a profitable enterprise. He sold a manifesto (the catalogue preface) and even planned to sell photographs of his canvases, effectively bypassing the jury to sell directly to the public.
The Cathedral of the Ego (1867)
Courbet’s ambition only grew with time. When the next Universal Exhibition arrived in 1867, he repeated the experiment, but on a gigantic scale. He commissioned a new pavilion at the Alma roundabout, not to be confused with that of the young Manet, this time built of stone.
He called this structure his "cathedral," situated in "the most beautiful spot that exists in Europe". Inside this personal museum, he exhibited 115 works, creating a permanent retrospective of his career. He boasted that he had "astounded the whole world". Although the land eventually had to be returned and the materials dismantled (ironically later used for barricades during the Paris Commune), Courbet had proven that an artist could survive—and thrive—without the state. He had transformed the "vile multitude" of his realism into a spectacle that the world could not ignore and paved the way for future independent exhibitions.
This blog is based on the anthologies of primary sources edited by Art d'Histoire Academy.
The complete academic references are available in the following publication:
You can also access the Art d'Histoire channel and its traditional videos:
We believe in making academic art history accessible and reliable for all.
The Art d’Histoire Academy platform specialises in primary sources and digitised archives, covering French art history from 1850 to 1910.
It offers clear, structured, interactive videos, as well as a library of over a thousand articles that explain and contextualise primary sources.
Whether you are preparing for an exam, exhibition or publication, the Art d’Histoire Academy will support you.
